Today, let’s talk about how to keep your stranded knitting nice and even looking! I’ll cover a few things that tie together to make that happen, and give you my best advice for lovely looking stranded knitting.
You may or may not find that your tension changes from knitting with one color to knitting with two colors. Many people say your tension tightens up when you knit stranded (producing more stitches per inch than when you knit with one color), or that you get more relaxed as you go. You won’t really know until you try it out for yourself.
Using the same yarn, my gauge is pretty much consistent whether I’m knitting with one color or two. What’s this all mean? That you will need to do a gauge swatch for a stranded knitting project. Period, end of story. It’s okay though, because you’ll want to do one anyway to make sure you like how your colors play together. (We’ll cover that in another post soon!)
Floats and puckers
When you work in stranded knitting, only one color is being used in a stitch at a time, obviously. So the other color waits for you at the back of the work, to get knit with the next time it’s needed. That strand of yarn between the stitches of a given color is often referred to as a ‘float’.
You want to make sure that your floats are not too tight.
I can’t emphasize that enough.
How? When you stop using color A and start using color B, do not tug tightly on that strand of yarn or you’ll pull your float too tight. If you do that, your work will end up puckered. You can block some of this out, but you simply can’t beat your knitting into submission, much as you may try.
When you go to knit with the next color in your pattern, knit that stitch but don’t yank on the yarn to tighten it up, just keep it nice and loose. That will help keep the float loose at the back of the work, ultimately leading to nice and even colorwork. Because it’s worth repeating: you want the yarn at the back of your work to be carried along loosely. You can always tighten up a stitch or two here and there but it’s almost impossible to loosen up floats that are too tight. Really!
I pulled out an old work-in-progress to show you a comparison. This isn’t an extreme example, but you can kind of see the puckered part from the strands between the red and black colors being pulled too tightly as I knit. (This project was on double-pointed needles, not my favorite way to do stranded knitting. Hence this being a WIP a few years later.)
Now, don’t panic—your work may be a little puckery looking as you knit it. That’s okay, and will block out. (Actually the above might even block out, but it’s best to not chance it.)
Take a look.
My secret to even stranded knitting
I’ve been thinking for weeks about what I do to keep my stranding nice and even, and I’ve really only come up with one little trick, but it’s the best tip I can give. It’s so easy, too!
I think some people have a tendency to scrunch up all the stitches close together on the needle when they do stranded knitting. Here’s what that looks like, with the stitches on the needle in my right hand scrunched up together, i.e. the stitches that just got knit.
Don’t do this.
Instead, when you’re knitting, keep the stitches on your right-hand needle slightly spaced apart. Give them some breathing room.
When you get to the next color in your row, make sure those stitches on your right-hand needle are nice and spaced apart.
In my next post (which will be very soon!), I’ll talk about dealing with vintage stranded patterns that do not have charts, how to chart them to save yourself oodles of time and frustration, and how to work with charts easily. Then we’ll talk a little bit about colors and yarn, and swatching!
Now do you have tips for what keeps your stranded knitting looking great? Please share in the comments!
This is fantastic!! Great pictures! I am so glad you are doing this, it’s truly inspiring me! Are those “Signature” needles?
I look forward to your next post!
YAY! Excellent post, as always. 🙂
I already spied some things I was doing incorrectly which was leading to some slight puckers on my first (& currently hibernating) stranded vest. I have a tendency to run before walking so perhaps my new color stranding project should be smallish and not a whole sweater. heh
I can’t imagine how much time it took you to put together this post… The colors in the images are so vibrant and I love the side-by-side images with ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ along with the handy text within the images. YOu have mega blogging skills! 🙂
Hi, Tasha and Zilredlo,
To use an appropriately vintage and very accurate phrase, “You took the words right out of my mouth!” This article is wonderfully helpful, mostly because, as Zilredlo pointed out, you obviously put a great deal of effort into it.
It was also an eye-opener as to how tricky this lovely technique is, and the wisdom of starting small, (definitely no sweaters!), but how rewarding mastering it would be.
Thank you so much for taking the time to help bring back a wonderful art form!
My new years resolution is to try fair isle knitting so this post was hugely helpful, thanks! Your cardigan from the last post is just beautiful, cant believe you made that, such skill! 🙂
Thanks so much! This was so wonderfully informative. I’ve been a little nervous about trying stranded knitting, but I think this may have convinced me 🙂
You are such a knitting pro! <3 I wish I was better!
Lost in the Haze
@knittyknoddy Yes, those are Signatures! I do love them, although I’m starting to like Chiagoo red lace needles even better for colorwork, since the cable is a bit more stiff and keeps the work held nicely while I knit.
@zilredloh Thanks, Liz! I really appreciate the kind comments. I have been working on making my tutorial photos as helpful as possible!
Rachel Proffitt says
I always loved Elizabeth Zimmerman’s tip- which was similar to yours. She recommended that as you switch colours you actually pull your right hand needle stitches to the right a little to increase that float size.
I too have the dpns issue- I did the first of my Christmas stockings on them and there is a definite tendency towards puckering. I am pretty sure it will block out when I get around to blocking it 😉 since it is slight- but you can see the contrast to the stocking I knit on a 16″ circular instead- the circ stocking came out WAY bigger LOL
I have been trying to aim some of my blog readers this way whenever they comment on wishing they could do stranded work as in my stockings 🙂
Betty Crafter says
I used to have a heck of a time with puckered stranded knitting as I’m a very tight knitter. Two things solved my problem. The first is spreading out the stitches on the right hand needle as you show. The other is catching my floats every 2 or 3 stitches so my floats aren’t very long. I’d be interested to know if you do this also, or how long you’ll let a float get before catching it.
@Betty Crafter Good question! I honestly don’t catch floats unless there is a really long space between stitches. Something like 11 stitches in fingering weight, for example. I know some people do it as frequently as every couple of stitches! I also only try to catch a float in a spot where the same/similar color was under that stitch in the row below, otherwise my ‘catch’ had a tendency to peek through on the right-side of the knitting.
Second Hand Rose says
Thanks so much for all the great advice and tutorial. I love your knitting needles! I never thought about the scrunching up thing but I will definitely try out your tips! XxxX http://thesecondhandrose.blogspot.com/
Thank you so much for this tutorial! I am making a Christmas sweater for my sweetie that I wasn’t looking forward to as much, mostly because my flats are always too tight. I tried this technique today and it looks soooo lovely!
Belated reply… if I’m in an area where I’m worried that my float will be too tight, I’ll work a YO in the middle of the float with the floating color, then drop it on the next row. I usually do this if I plan to catch it on the next row: I work that YO right next to the one I want to catch it on, then on the next row I just drop it over. The YO gives me the extra length I need so that the added height doesn’t pull it too tight.
@kalany – Neat tip, I’ll have to try that some time!
Super helpful tips – thanks for that!
Let me start by saying how much I like your site. Love the look of it, the photos are gorgeous and the feel of it is nostalgic. I discovered it when searching for stranded colorwork help. Yours is the first thing I clicked on and I’ve had to look no further. The above article was exactly what I needed to get me on my way to starting stranded colorwork. Thank you so much!
I have a question: I’m currently working on a glove, and I’m using red and black. The thing is that, I used black and red so often on 7 rows, that the floats are pretty small. Then, my pattern switches to 7 black, and then 1 red, creating a really big float, and then, I ended up having to knit red halfway through the row, and then add a few black stitches in the middle of the row, which created an even bigger float than the other ones. I was wondering if there’s a way to make the floats neat so that when I put on my glove, my fingers won’t entagled with the huge floats.
Thank you so much, the pictures illustrate really clearly. I am practicing ready for an intricate cushion design for my Mum for Xmas, and now I feel pretty surer I can achieve this! Thanks again.
This tutorial has SAVED my fair isle work! On my first project I was getting terrible puckers and it just didn’t look that pretty, but once I started spacing as you’ve suggested, it’s been awesome! Blocking did help even everything out beautifully, but I’d prefer it was pretty all along.
Here’s a link to the project completed on my Ravelry page! Thanks again!
Barbara R. says
Thank you for such a great tutorial!
Mona M says
Thank you so much. Last year I tried to make an Arne and Carlos Christmas ball for my daughter. I ended up with a square sided ball, because of the puckers! It was my first attempt at knitting with dpns and colour work. I shall try again, using your tips.
Hi there! I’m very new to stranded knitting and find your tips really helpful. I have a question: Do you recommend hiding/weaving your threads prior to blocking? Or after blocking? My first stranded hat looks a bit like one in your photo of ‘before blocking’. I was about to rip it and start again until I saw your ‘after blocking’ pic — blocking looks like it helps smooth out some of the uneven stitches. But I was unsure if it mattered when I hid my threads. Thanks!
I wish there were only a way to fix projects that were knit too tightly in color work. The puckering is a real problem with my french ‘cotton fifty’ yarn dishcloth I have been making. My robot pattern is all bunched up! This is my third time doing complex color work and needless to say I am frustrated! Thanks for the advice, I will keep it in mind in the future.
Jenny Walkley says
Just finished frogging a beautiful colorwork blanket about 10″ in due to puckering. I’m a continental knitter who strangles her knitting to death!! I intend to use some of the advice here to practice before tackling this project again. I really, really want to do this right! 🙂
Great advice. You have confirmed where I thought I was going wrong and given me some great tips. Thanks heaps.
I just found your blog ! Great advice! Love your content!
Lisa Whiting says
Hi, thanks for this great thread! I am having problems with my Fair Isle being the right tension width but too long length so the pattern is a tad distorted. Is this because I am knitting too tight and distorting the ratio as the bit uncharted was fine for both? I am already using 2.25mm needles for 4ply so can’t go down any. Just wondered what I was doing wrong! Thanks!
Kathy M says
I implemented this advice and it helped quite a bit. However, I am still having something weird going on when I turn the corner from purling to knitting in my fair isle stockinette knitting square (from the Arne & Carlos coronavirus lockdown knit-along). I end up with a hole at the spot where the accent color ends for the last time. I think it’s because the last stitch of that color is being pulled back toward the center of the work instead of continuing to the edge, because I’m not carrying that yarn all the way to the edge. In other words, that yarn is turning a corner to go back the other way before the edge of the work so that last “V” is getting pulled kind of into a |/. Does that make sense to anyone? Is there any way to fix this?
Kathy M says
Oops – Edit of my above comment:
I end up with a hole at the spot where the accent color STITCHING ends for the last time IN THAT ROW.